Is diy co2 worth it. Once it starts to flow, it is steady.
Is diy co2 worth it Not all CO2 devices are built the same, don’t believe any doctor that says “a CO2 is a CO2” that is not true. These valves are designed to open automatically at a certain pressure level to discharge fluid if too much gas builds up. When I had mine setup, I found it worked great, and consistently, when the room temperature was I've successfully used DIY CO2 with a chopstick diffuser to build plant mass on a low tech higher light setup. I have been doing a lot of reading and it looks to me that CO2 really needs to be in the water for a bit before it diffuses into in. Maybe add a thin layer of mineral oil to float on top of the water. perfectgardens. It lets me dose ferts and up my lighting to get plants established without a huge algae outbreak. Does a DIY one produce sufficient pressure? Click to expand is there a way I can make out from the picture if designed for high pressure . That said, it is something worth to consider if you just try to improve on plants that would be fine in low-tech regardless. Proper Co2 injection is a much better option, and you can do DIY much cheaper using parts readily available on ebay It can definitely work but honestly an actual co2 setup is SOOO worth it if you are serious about this hobby and wanna keep high tech aquariums. Best CO2 Reactors Compared & Reviewed. Wasn't worth the added trouble and cost. From the research I did, I didn’t want the unreliability of DIY, so I went full pressurized. Probably not but who knows. I tried the exotic yeasts, like brewers yeast and champagne yeast. Anthony A Primer to Pressurized CO2 and A Primer to Planted Tanks Eheim Pimp #362 - Eheim Pro 4+ 350, Eheim 2217, Eheim 2213 x2, By running the CO2 24/7, it's always available. Second is that bread yeast is really uneven, the first day or two you get almost too much co2 and then it quickly putters out. 00 difference, is it worth it to spend more for a 2 Stage? Thanks. My advice is that you push the tubing from the yeast and sugar mixture further down into the plain water bottle. I don't suppose anyone knows where to find T-slot type aluminium profiles in Swiss or close border countries (France preferably, or Pressurized. Reply reply More replies More replies. suggest that either the output gets places in the direct line of the filter output so it swirls around the tank and has time to dissolve, or put the CO2 output near, or directly in, the filter input so it gets swirled around and dissolved in the filter. FZONE Aquarium Co2 Regulator DC Solenoid with Big Dual Gauge Display and Bubble Counter and Check Valve Plant Grow DIY IMO If you want to make it CO2 worth it, just save up a bit more and invest in one of the tested and reliable ways like a tank or burner. Then worry about the CO2 at some point in the future. This would be for my 40 gallon tank. Top 2% Rank by size . The reactor was taking the end cap off my Ehiem 2217 outflow bar and attaching a short hose to it and attaching that to a gravel siphon/cleaner and drilled a hole Hi all, A couple days ago I set up a DIY inline CO2 reactor for my 30G using Ghazanfar Ghori's plans-- basically a 10"-long, 2"-diameter PVC pipe filled with bio-balls and sporting a hose connector on each end. On average it should cost about 160$ give or take. Also, I had a really hard time dialing in the amount of co2 coming out and found it to be pretty inconsistent (adjusting it several times a day). It is necessary to clean this film with a toothbrush each week to ensure CO2 can be released. is it really worth it to go through that hassle every week? I found on eBay where I could get the regulator, bubble counter, and diffuser for about $50 all My question is do you find DIY CO2 worth it (cost wise) versus that of Flourish Excel? Here is my experience and my cost numbers: I'm running a BioCube 14 rimless, a Planted+ 20", a DIY CO2 system that consists of the soda bottle Citric Acid setup, a bubble counter, and a diffuser that has been both in the filter and mostly in the tank under Liquid CO2 doesn’t do the same thing as gas CO2. Keep it simple, make sure there are no leaks in your system and be patient. it doesnt make it easy just more productive I havent yet quantified my results with others who have simular set ups I Here's the difference between DIY and a bottle: 5LB bottle you fill maybe every 2 to 3 months depending on how much gas you use. I think the biggest advantage with pressurized is having more precise control and higher volume. 5 bubbles per second out of it. So either your machine is leaking CO2 somewhere, or you're drinking a lot of seltzer. I still had a bubble counter and co2 diffuser. I like using liquid CO2 to help with algae. More posts you may like r 652K subscribers in the Aquariums community. Otherwise you'd have to set up two reactors and spend twice as much each time. Do not mix. Sodastream machines are nice, but for the true seltzer addict, a do-it-yourself carbonation system can be cheaper, more flexible, and more fun Hello I need to purchase a CO2 pressurized system because I have more black beard algae in my tank that I can deal with right now. 95grm per watt for what its worth Id say co2 is a must. Then get a CO2 regulator with a solenoid. Costs me $10 cash at local diy beer supply place to fill the co2 and it lasts wayyyyyy longer than the soda I've been doing a lot of research in seeing if co2 is worth getting and running. But first work on getting a good light (plants can't grow in the dark - or with bad lights). Once it starts to flow, it is steady. Imo when it comes to co2, I only use high quality and reliable regulator and solenoids from gla or co2art. Diy is not consistent. I see both pros and cons. Does DIY CO2 explode? Registered. A little expensive to start but totally worth it in terms of ease. If you're going high tech anyways just invest in a CO2 canister, even a paintball-sized one, and have a regulator dispense your bubbles at a predictable rate. My advice on DIY CO2 is don't. I seem to take well to the lasers and I have a fairly high pain tolerance I think Diffusing the CO2. Definitely invest in CO2. Stay away from the “Fraxel” brand of CO2, and other brands as well, again stick to Lumenis UltraPulse which can be utilized for fractional treatment (TotalFX = DeepFx + ActiveFX). Got the Milwaukee regulator/bubble counter/solenoid for $90 and a 5lb co2 tank filled from a local place for $65. At that low bubble rate, the CO2 concentration is lower than the recommended level of a one-point drop in pH, but the plants do just fine with the constant low flow. Here, we exchange before-and-after photos, share DIY advice, provide equipment recommendations, and more. When I ran . We breathe I thought about doing a CO2 laser also. Follow our rules, participate actively, and enjoy the radiant clean finishes. pH 7. A good quality diffuser is inexpensive and crucial for efficiently dissolving CO2 into the water. for DIY co2 you can just get a couple 2 liters, some silicone, airline tubing, yeast, and sugar, and a bubble ladder or airstone. Then when the plant mass got large enough I weaned off the CO2. The addition of CO2 on my first planted tank also increased algae. I ran DIY CO2 on my 40 for a couple months before finally upgrading to pressurized. A glass diffuser is a cheap and obvious choice. L. Its hardly a heavily planted tank Personally I do think CO2 is worth it, as otherwise it’s Botox. At a CO2 level of 0 the growth rate of a plant is negative, not positive. Is Co2 worth running to you guys? I want some more plant growth, I'd like a jungle. with ceramic diffuser you may not have enough pressure in the co2 system to handle it properly. Simply putting the hose in Getting your hands on a co2 meter is necessary to see if it's worth it. I actually just set up my first DIY yeast based CO2 system last week! Honestly worked better than I thought. This works extremely well for 1-30 gallon tanks. What is a CO2 Laser Cutter? A CO2 laser cutter is a machine that uses a high-powered laser beam generated by a gas-filled tube to cut or engrave various materials. However I use jello with a little extra sugar. I was wondering if it would be worth my time making two DIY CO2 kits. My dwarf hairgrass even looked greener. I'm sure that it encourages plant growth and provides optimal conditions to get big and healthy plants. be/gYqXFkl9Xk8I set up t It would be interesting to add this sensor to the mix and see which method really works the best, and see how much co2 we are actually making. It's really not as complicated as all these "DIY Not Working" threads make out. If you’re still wondering whether this DIY project is worth your while, then stick around as we journey through the entire process, and look Sometimes, I think people try to over think the whole DIY CO2 thing and it ends up being a mess. It should also be noted that CO₂ gas from a refillable bottle is cheaper in running costs. Home; Forum; Help. Below are some things to consider when trying to figure out is diy co2 worth it. IMO CO2 is something you should do right or don't bother. The subreddit for anything related to aquariums! Come here to enjoy pictures, videos, articles and In this article, we explore the process of building a CO2 laser cutter and discuss whether it is worth the time and effort. There will be no more aquarium video from this channel. Nothing wrong with yeast for CO2, it costs basically nothing and makes a noticeable improvement. We have tested many types of DIY systems using yeast, citric acid, and other mixtures, and while they may be cheaper, they are not as stable as a pressurized CO2 system using a regulator and cylinder. I would consider 3 - 4 of the 2 liter soda bottles should get you started. Trying to create a piercing device at home wasn't going so hot and I stumbled upon a backup device for the paintballers that uses those cheap little co2 cartridges. Cons of DIY: A diy setup will give you very inconsistent co2 pressure/supply which will cause crazy algae issues. I've had diode lasers for years and just don't think they are any good at cutting stuff. However for DIY CO2 it can become clogged with a fine film that is a byproduct of the yeast. That being said running an air stone really won't do anything. Also if your planning to use co2 just get a 5# cylinder or whatever size depending on your tank, worth the investment. Share Is diy co2 worth it for a 63 gallon tank? I quit making aquarium video. Is it worth the effort? Thread starter Ketso; Start date Feb 19, 2007; The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping! If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts. I've used one of the Fluval 88 systems. And during those couple months, my plants definitely made a turn around. You may have to buy a CO2 diffuser and tubing (or bundle with the regulator). I've had luck without C02 In the past. I recently upgraded from DIY to pressurized about a month and a half ago. The advantage to the 1540 laser is that there is no social down time and no loss of work. CO2 Diffuser: I initially tried making my own CO2 diffuser using various DIY methods, but honestly, it wasn't worth the hassle. A 20W diode laser will cut many of the same things a 40W CO2 laser will. High quality full spectrum lighting on for 13 hours per day. My new content will be like this:https://youtu. 1. Look in your phone book. The question of "is premium lighting worth it?" depends on some important factors for your aquarium goals: Factors in Favor of Budget Lighting. Is the same kind of growth achievable with out CO2 along with Here are some of my observations with DIY co2. I prefer the CO2 burners, personally, as propane is cheap and easily obtained, and it helps keep my grow room temperatures up in the winter time. My only variation from Ghori's plan was that instead of gluing the airline connector directly into the pipe, I just drilled a A single, room temperature canister of CO2 is 950psi. Pros of DIY: Cheap, works pretty well for small tanks, can run for 2-3 months if your recipe is right and you use a strong, temperature tolerant yeast like champagne. When I did the DIY Co2 I used 2-3 liter coke bottles connecting to a T to have single out 1/4" out hose connected to a homemade bubble counter then ran the tube to a homemade reactor. 7degC. Simple. If you placed a plant in a room with 0 CO2 the plant would attempt to continue growing, thus consuming energy. 0 ammonia and nitrite and about 20-40ppm nitrate. Also the aquariums I run co2 on currently are all 75g+ and 3/4 run sumps while the 4th has a giant sponge filter with an airstone in it going 24/7 (it was supposed to just be for skipping cycling but I just let it stay in there because I've overstocked it. It requires more effort, and most tend to go over to pressurized because the time and effort, and added The graph you posted is incorrect. I have a fully sealed co2 enriched grow its amazing if it wasnt for the co2 my first grow would have been avarage at best I have recorded growth rates of 6" per day and . The smell was awful with a capital AWFUL. For me it was totally worth it (just dont forget to re make it I got a bad algae bloom cause I got sick and forgot to check the pressure and it was empty for a week or 2) Reply I have been using my own diy co2 ever since I got into the hobby. It I started off DIY CO2 with the Baking Soda and Citric Acid method and I still use it on my 20 gallon. The standard SodaStream cartridges hold just under a pound of CO2, and carbonate a nominal 60L of seltzer. This is a small tank with total It seems like all the suggestions for placement of CO2 output that I’ve seen on tutorials and websites etc. It might seem like a bit of an investment but its worth it to get the right stuff from the beginning. That's pretty impressive. It's either smelly (yeast CO2) or space inefficient (Citric acid CO2). I’ve seen a lot of people on here saying that a DIY co2 system isn’t worth the hassle. With no CO2 in the room the plant is unable to go through the process of photosynthesis, thus it is producing no energy itself. If you're going high tech anyways just invest in a CO2 canister, even a paintball-sized one, and have a regulator dispense your DIY CO2 certainly works, and works quite well, with the caveat of temperature. Personally I don't think it's worth the hassle and CO2 really isn't that expensive to set up there is an initial cost but after that you're just buying CO2. Now that you’ve got an idea about what makes a CO2 reactor worth your bucks, let’s jump into the reviews. I used the two (2l) bottle method, but the constant shaking, messy refilling, and inconsistent gas exchange were just not worth it to me for the long run. Ebay 'emergency co2' and you'll see quite a few. Might be switching to citric acid. The alternatives can cause more problems then they're worth. So I'm not going to lie, after a couple hours of researching diy co2, it doesn't seem worth the trouble. Witness the magic of renewing surfaces with high-powered cleaning. Furthermore,is co2 worth it aquarium? CO2 injection/liquid carbon is essential in aquariums with high lighting levels. If size is an issue use a regulator designed for a paintball tank. I'm guessing that this gives me a more stable pH -- that the increase in CO2 and reduction in O2 production by plants at night will somewhat compensate for the reduction of injected CO2, leading to a more stable pH. I used two 2L bottles and got a pretty steady 1-1. Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using Tapatalk . It would be nice to use a drop checker to see if your DIY CO2 system was doing any good at all, raising the amount of CO2 in the water enough to make it worth the effort. Hopefully this will push the CO2 laser makers to make more meaningful upgrades. by http://sinceresell. Now for the answer you’ve been waiting for: yes, you can create a DIY CO2 generator using vinegar and baking soda. I had DIY co2 for 2 months (baking soda and citric acid) and it caused me nothing but issues. Mostly because the room in my shop that I want the CO2 laser only has a 34" wide door. It works fine and is consistent. I’m not against Botox, I just find CO2 more cost effective (plus the wrinkles are so near my brow that Botox lowers my brow which I don’t like) My skin is not very sensitive. Then I remembered those little co2 cartridges I used my bb gun as a kid, a plan was hatched. I say go for it and see what happens. This budget-friendly method can provide the extra CO2 your plants need to thrive. I just had to get a regulator and a tank. CO2 reactors are closed systems that can explode if the pressure increases. Well worth it. However, I'd suggest against even trying DIY CO2. There's a tremendous amount of pressure (more than x4 as much) for the gun to handle, which means, instead of a "blow back" function, you're essentially making the gun break itself into pieces. For larger aquariums you must use more DIY bottles to increase CO2 output. 25 Gallon Journal. EDIT: temp 25. Its totally worth it if you do it right. I messed around with diy crap until my buddy with a real co2 grow brought his meter. Your tank ecosystem also would not enjoy a volatile change of co2 as Materials Needed. (For me it's closer to 40L because I like to carbonate heavily). Try to use bag seeds if you got any The drawback with the ICON 1540 is that you need several treatments to get the same kind of results that you can get from the one ablative CO2 laser treatment. Fractional CO2 has 10 days of downtime. Is it worth it to spend a few hundred dollars more for a 2 Stage Furnace? I haven’t seen the quotes yet but if it is less than a 500. Will have to see how the reaction goes as we move into colder weather. You can get that if you use . after fucking around with those bags for too long, I finally ordered a tank and regulator to do it right. I have this hooked up to my 12 long, didn't want to spend another $300 for a full setup. Transform Your Planted Aquarium on a Budget! Ready to take your aquatic garden to the next level? Dive into my EASIEST Low Budget DIY CO2 System for your pla For those that used CO2 would you recommend? Did it make a good difference? All tanks are cycled, all fish are happy, algae growing slowly in 2 of the tanks and needs 2 weekly cleaning. I have a 10 gallon tank that I want to start up a DIY co2 system. For years, they've been upselling from 40 to 45 watt laser tubes, or 45 to 60 watt. First, I run it through a check valve, and this seems to hold back the flow till the pressure builds enough to push pass the check valve. You need 3-7 sessions of 1540 vs 1 CO2 laser treatment. You will be always fighting the high pressure thing, with risk to get an explosion. DIY Co2 for your Aquarium – How To . I just run it 24/7 with ample surface agitation Honestly its worth it to just get this instead of wasting money on dyi kits or overpriced specialty set ups from the fish store. 00 advertised as Aquarium CO2 pressurized systems. TinyPortal; Search; Login; Register; Tropical Fish Forums UK » ; Forum » ; The Aquarium. That is why CO2 ruins guns. I cant seem to find them for this price, but when reading baout these diy co2 generators, one of the replys was "now we need someone to figure out how to nake a controller out of a $30 sensor. I saw a cheap CO2 devices for $60. I've seen a lot of support for the use of CO2 in freshwater but have been wondering if it really makes that much of a difference. A place for aquatic flora and fauna enthusiasts! Whether you have a question to ask or a planted tank Just wondering if DIY co2 system is worth the effort? I mean it's not the hardest thing to make, but with the fluctuating co2 levels it produces is it still Co2 worth it? Jump to Latest 2K views 8 replies 6 participants last post by tug Sep 28, 2009. See posts with no answers. It's not worth the effort, it's not worth your time, and it's not worth your money. I already had a drop checker and a glass diffuser for DIY. A HOB filter is likely to outgas a significant amount of the CO2 before it can be used by the plants, so I wouldn't try that. I was curious if a sugar solution with a distillers yeast would be as effective. Those already mentioned co2 art, fzone, uns, coop aquarium are all good--consider buying a dual stage regulator. To be honest I hate them and feel that if people want to get into co2 they should skip DIY co2. I'm confident with everything except the diffuser at the end. I tried diy yeast/sugar co2 once and it leaked once. I ran DIY citric acid CO2 for 2 weeks and every plant grew noticeably faster. But my plants seem to have a little bit of a hard time, as they won't grow past the stage they are in. Gas source (in the case of a burner style machine): machines that burn gas to produce CO2 are quite popular because they do not require power; hey are like a gas grill that has a supply of gas and 326K subscribers in the PlantedTank community. wordpress. Here is a link for DIY CO2. I have a 2L yeast generator that has been running since January, and is just now getting time to refill it. Or even with building your own Co2 laser from scratch? then I feel it won't be worth it anyway. BBA type algae will easily occur when you have fluctuating co2 levels - especially when the co2 levels are sort of borderline to begin with. The combination of high lighting and CO2 injection will result in super-fast plant growth and therefore more maintenance via regular pruning and water changes. I would suggest either bottled CO2 or a CO2 burner. LMuhlen I hope thats investment was worth with the plants I used for my ambitious aqiascape. I absolutely do not have the budget for a proper system, but I could spare $25 and some change for parts for a diy system ($10 diffuser, $7 drop checker, $10? tubing) plus some household goods. Inverted bottle: route the CO2 into an inverted bottle/cup etc that inside the tank so CO2 collects in the container, the interaction with the bottom surface of the CO2 and the tank water will elevate the CO2 levels tank wide. 6 hard water. A lot of those diffusers are designed for high pressure CO2 systems. comItem Description :Up - aqua NEW ATOMIZER SYSTEM aquarium Co2 diffuser 12/16mmItem Used Experience :DIY Co2 available! Actu do have a proper CO2 system but it's expensive to maintain (getting new CO2 cans) what if I use a proper CO2 system once a week every month and then use a DIY CO2 system for the rest of the month ,also I'm planning on getting low tech plants Is DIY Co2 worth it? I’m just getting back into growing and I’ve seen the “exhale” bags. Listed below are more suitable methods for DIY CO2. I find that it lasts longer than plain sugar water. crimsonbull57 It holds consistent pressure and bubble rate through a diffuser that is compatible with DIY CO2 systems - so be sure to look for that compatibility statement. Yeah it works, but it is more trouble than it's worth. With that kind of price it's not worth the hassle. The DIY reactions often make lots of CO2 at the beginning and then decline over time, and the inconsistent amounts of C. The pressure and CO2 release are consistent and steady right up until the bottle is nearly exhausted, and you have a gauge to warn you. It's currently located somewhere in a landfill. It’s just a tool that I use to help keep my tanks balanced. com/collections/grow-help/products/grow Has anyone got experience with DIY Co2 laser cutter kits? Kits with everything included except for the enclosure. My CO2 monitor totally noticed the change and I had to decrease flow rate after 1 day/night cycle of use. Amazon sells empty CO2 tanks, you can get it filled at local welding supply companies (some sells CO2 tanks too). Again, IMO pressurized is the way to go for a 75 gallon. Your run-of-the-mill DIY reactor. Trying to regularly swap between a cartridge system and a diy system will make it I would steer clear of the DIY or other low end CO2 methods you mentioned. Yeah it works, but it is more trouble than it's worth. Now that I’ve had my Co2 up and running for awhile, I When people go through the hassle of setting up much larger DIY co2 setups and struggle to raise the co2 ppm above atmospheric levels (~400ppm) even in a small closet or grow tent I would say that it is pretty unsuccessful considering a cheap co2 tank setup can actually achieve the desired 1200-1500ppm levels. Staying on top of it becomes a pestersome chore. Is it worth it to build a diy system or just run my tank with Having Co2 in my tank and seeing how much more lush, vibrant, and beautiful my tanks are makes it all worth it. Also with the DIY stuff you're going to have to constantly tinker with it. I just plug the powerhead into the same timer as the lights. Reply reply Diy co2 is great but its volatile and needs much more frequent refilling and checking to make sure its going well. DIY CO2 on one of my later tanks also helped BBA, which often results from inconsistent CO2, like that of a DIY kit. Feb 6, 2015 #1 My boy grows under water plants for his fish tank and he make his own co2 gen. » The DIY CO2 is a matter of taking Yeast and Sugar, and mixing them with water to create a reaction by product of CO2 gas. I use the internal powerhead reactor approach for my DIY CO2. Not enough the best part about getting chemfuel made in biofuel refinery is you can just focus on food without needing to worry about wood not to mention chemfuel generator have about 2x the efficiency of wood generator, it's not as much after you If you're in a larger space like a room, these bags won't work. For that you are more interested in CO2 ppm's from about 5 to 20 ppm, and you can't get that using 4 dKH water in the drop checker. So no, CO2 is not good to use UNLESS the gun is designed for it. That's not an easy task without real co2 equipment, monitors and sealed grows. All pretty DIY CO2 is almost always on the low end of being enough to do much good, so I think it is worth the effort to find a way to make the diffusing process as efficient as you can. Tread carefully, and remember that success comes from research and experience! Seachem Excel and the like is an algaecide, it works by killing off the algea that grows on plants giving the plants more access to the CO2 that is in the water from regular gas exchange. Someone here will likely come along and insist DIY CO2 doesn't work and you should just invest in a pressurized system. To get a big enough CO2 laser to do what I want to means the machines are like 80"x50"x40". ) DIY Co2. I fed my CO2 into the input of my Aquaclear HOB (hang on back) filter and used it as the diffuser. For what it's worth, whatever little kit I bought on Amazon for 25 bucks has been working great for coming up on 8 years and there's was no skill needed just screwed it in to my own 5lb bottle and screwed it in to the soda stream. Probably because I was inexperienced and did not know how to balance everything. Login with username, password and session length. Low to medium light plants can often thrive under budget LEDs. algae. 75 dKH water. Low-Tech Approach: With no CO2 injection, the plants you can grow successfully will be limited anyway. » The There IS starting to be overlap between the low end of CO2 lasers and the high end of diode lasers. 1 2lt bottle, 2 cups sugar, fill with warm water, add yeast. dissolving Co2 tabs, are they worth it? Jump to Latest and they are a very expensive alternative to either DIY CO2 and/or pressurized CO2. I have 5 gallon carboy a from home brewing, so I was going to run a tube from the carboy right split it off and hang it over my plants with an air stone to disperse the Hey guys. Too big to get in the door. DIY Co2 Generator, worth it? Thread starter simply_slide; Start date Feb 6, 2015; simply_slide Well-Known Member. I don't want to kill your dreams but I want you to be aware that DIY co2 really isn't anymore helpful than dosing seachem excel in my opinion. It doesn’t wipe out all algae but it keeps it at a very manageable level. 00-$70. Pressurized CO2 doesn't have to cost 300$. CO2 - Do I need it in my grow room?Check out our Membership ProgramsVIP Membership - https://www. You have better control. 1200-1500ppms for plants to benifit. Now DIY beyond a 30 gallon tank would probably be ridiculous I think 30 is near the max of 'being worth it' to me. At $20, it was worth a shot. but I just bought a nano co2 diffuser off eBay for 5 backdrop shipped. Most of these diy co2 things are gimmicks. eounl ejwb sqv erau eecpkkn cxcy znz acnjy gtpvkrp rup ltwf nzigmyl sqvkbe lmci ywtvmqc